Choosing Your Roofing Material
Your roofing material affects cost, lifespan, energy efficiency, aesthetics, and even insurance premiums. Asphalt shingles dominate the market (80%+ of U.S. homes), but metal and tile have compelling advantages for the right situation. Here's the full picture.
Material Comparison
| Criteria | Asphalt Shingles (Architectural) | Standing Seam Metal | Concrete/Clay Tile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Installed Cost (per square) | $350-$550/square installed | $700-$1,200/square installed | $800-$1,800/square installed |
| Expected Lifespan | 20-30 years | 40-70 years | 50-100+ years |
| Wind Resistance | Good (110-130 MPH rated) | Excellent (140+ MPH rated) | Good when properly installed (fastened, not just set) |
| Hail Resistance | Moderate (Class 3-4 impact rated available) | Excellent (dents but doesn't crack or leak) | Poor (concrete) to moderate (clay) — tiles crack under impact |
| Energy Efficiency | Standard (reflective options available) | Excellent (reflects solar heat, reduces cooling costs 10-25%) | Good (airspace under tiles provides insulation) |
| Maintenance Needs | Low — occasional inspection, gutter cleaning | Very low — occasional fastener check | Moderate — individual tiles can crack and need replacement |
| Weight | Light (2-4 lbs/sq ft) | Very light (1-2 lbs/sq ft) | Heavy (8-12 lbs/sq ft — may require structural reinforcement) |
| Insurance Discount Potential | Standard rates; impact-resistant shingles may qualify for 10-25% discount | Often qualifies for 15-35% discount (wind/hail resistance) | Standard rates; fire resistance may help in wildfire zones |
Bottom Line: For most homeowners, architectural asphalt shingles (like GAF Timberline or Owens Corning Duration) offer the best balance of cost, durability, and aesthetics. They're the right choice for 80% of situations.
Standing seam metal is worth the premium if you live in a severe weather zone (hurricanes, hail), plan to stay in the home 20+ years, or want maximum energy efficiency and insurance savings. The 2-3X higher upfront cost is offset by 2-3X longer lifespan.
Tile is primarily an aesthetic/architectural choice popular in Mediterranean, Spanish, and Southwestern-style homes. The weight requires structural verification, and the fragility to hail makes it a poor choice in storm-prone areas. But nothing else matches its 100-year lifespan and timeless look.
Compare Your Roofing Quotes
Material choice is one of the biggest variables in a roofing quote. Upload your quotes to Zollera to see exactly what materials each contractor is proposing and how the total cost compares.
Ready to define your project scope?
Use the Project Builder to create a personalized checklist you can hand to every contractor.
Build your scopeReady to Compare Your Quotes?
You've done the research. Now upload your contractor quotes and get an instant side-by-side comparison in 60 seconds.
Already have quotes in mind? Search what others paid